Skip to main content

Apple Defies FBI, Refuses to Provide Backdoor Into iPhones

On 2 December 2015, two shooters killed 14 people and injured 22 in San Bernardino, California. Following frenzied media coverage, it was found that a Muslim couple went on the rampage.
Most of us have followed the developments of this case, with the case taking twists and turns regarding the couple’s allegiances and the chain of events that unfolded on that fateful December 2. The FBI for their part, went through all the clues, even confiscating the iPhone in the use of Syed Farok and Tashfeen Malik, the two shooters.
But little did they know that breaking through that iPhone’s encryption would be easier said than done.
As things stand, FBI moved the US courts over a warrant to unlock the security of the shooter’s iPhone. They were granted an order by the judge hearing the case, which brought them to Tim Cook’s doorstep.
Apple’s head honcho, suffice to say, was in no mood to entertain the court order.
FBI request sets a ‘dangerous precedent.’ –  Apple CEO Tim Cook
Is Tim Cook’s reaction surprising? Or was he supposed to kowtow to the demands of American domestic law enforcement? We take a look at the case.

Why is Tim Cook Fighting the Court Order to Grant Access on iPhones?

Normally, as all iOS users know, Apple;’s mobile OS has a feature that can automatically erase your data permanently if someone enters the wrong passcode 10 times on the device in question.
This is what the FBI told the court, and hence the reason behind the court’s order for Apple to unlock the iPhone or at least install a backdoor that law enforcement agencies can access in such cases.
“We’re not reading your email. We’re not reading your iMessages. If the government laid a subpoena on us to get your iMessages, we can’t provide it. It’s encrypted and we don’t have the key.” – Tim Cook in 2014
The seriousness of the case compelled Apple and its CEO to release a public letter, warning that complying with the court order means that users will suffer if the Cupertino-based company were to entail building “a backdoor to the iPhone” — “something we consider too dangerous to create.”

Why Does it Set a Dangerous Precedent?

Suppose Apple does build a backdoor into iPhones and complies with the court order. That will be akin to opening the gates of hell. Any American law enforcement agency would now be able to get its hands on the previously-secure data and abuse it for personal and corrupt means. Corporates only need to show them the money to get on the action.
Once America sets the course, other regimes around the world, be they dictatorial or theological or democratic, will also fight for the same kind of access. Echoes of a case concerning a Chinese blogger and Yahoo come to mind. We all know what happened to that Chinese blogger who aired views that didn’t sit well with the Chinese goverment. Mr. Wang Xiaoning was jailed for 10 years by the Chinese authorities in September 2013, with his wife fleeing to the US, facing similar fears of persecution.
If Yahoo’s abysmal stock value currently is anything to go by, you really can’t blame Apple to think otherwise. Apple’s prestige as a dominant tech leader would take a body blow if it decided to emulate Yahoo’s example. That’s a scenario that Cook and co. really don’t want to see happen.
And then there is your garden-variety hacker and cyber-criminal. Once you show them it can be done, then you can expect ever-increasing cases of ID thefts and stolen digital currency (i.e. Apple Wallet) becoming the order of the day, at least on iOS devices.
Cook also argued that there are no legal grounds for doing this, creating the software that can act as a backdoor for not just Farok’s iPhone but all iPhones around the world. And he also says that if he complies, then whats to say that they won’t ask other tech companies to fall into lines. Privacy advocates are also worried about the same.
Its understandable for a company (that’s worth $78 billion) to care about the security of its customers. On the other hand, it has to tread carefully since there are elements in America who would consider its defiance as nothing sort of ‘treasonous’ to say the least.

Is This Only Apple’s Fight?

Apple’s efforts to fight back have been lauded by its biggest competitors as well. Sundhar Pichai, Google’s CEO, also lent his support for his rival’s efforts. The Android OS that Google ships is the world’s dominant, and even though its open-source, Google’s model is predicated on collecting data from its users for its business. Imagine the implications of what that could do if Google complied with government orders.
So ask yourself, would you ever buy an Android or iOS device if it meant that their parent companies would hand over data about you to someone higher up in the governmental hierarchy. You can see the potential for abuse of power here. For terrorism-related cases, the line becomes that much murkier as we’ve seen in cases involving terrorist acts in Pakistani soil and how telecom companies worked in concert with the authorities to nab them. But one thing is for sure, this is, as Snowden says, ‘the most important tech case of the decade.’

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

OPPO’s Super VOOC can Fully Charge a Phone Battery in 15 Minutes

With every iteration of flagship phones, they get smarter and more powerful. However, one thing that remains seemingly stagnant is battery life. There has been little to no innovation in Lithium Ion batteries and increasing capacity brings its own challenges like higher charging time and the size of the phone. So instead of creating new batteries, companies have shifted their focus on faster charging and OPPO IS coming out with a bang. Super VOOC by OPPO is a battery charger that fully charges a mobile in just 15 minutes. Still in its prototype phase, Super VOOC Flash Charge, which is OPPO’s upgrade to VOOC Flash Charge, can charge a 2500mAh battery from 0-100% in just about 15 minutes. The technology can be used on both USB Type-C and Micro-USB. Super VOOC actually uses a 5v low voltage pulse algorithm that not only provides a safe charging and prevents overheating, the direct power transmission to the battery without any conversion, results in a 97% charging efficiency. T...

Huawei Mate 8 Review: A Powerhouse Phablet with Great Battery Life

Huawei launched the new Mate 8 in November 2015. Recently, the phone was released in Pakistan as well and we received our review unit sometime ago. Mate 8 is a 6.0″ phablet currently available in two variants, 32GB Storage w/ 3GB RAM for approximately 60,000/- PKR and 64GB Storage w/ 4GB RAM for around 70,000/- PKR We received a Golden Mate 8 review unit with 64GB storage and 4GB RAM. I’ve been using it as my daily driver for some while now and you can read all about my experience in the detailed Huawei Mate 8 review below. Design & Build Quality  •  Performance & Battery  •  User Interface  •  Camera Quality  •  Conclusion Packaging Huawei Mate 8 comes in a nice textured square box. Upfront. you’ll find the name of the device while the words “Huawei Design” and Huawei’s logo can be found on the sides of the box. In order to keep the design minimal, technical specs of the Mate 8 have been left out. Besides...

Apple CEO shares plans for the company's future in India

Apple's CEO Tim Cook is on an official visit in India, meeting up with the government and carriers to talk about the company's future in the country. Amidst those talks he went for an exclusive interview on NDTV, where he shared Apple's plans for making a move on the Indian market. For one, Apple sees India as having an "enormously bright future" and it's one Apple wants to be a part of. "We're here for a thousand years" were the exact words. Tim Cook sees the rollout of 4G as key to both India's future and Apple's part of it. Tim Cook was clear that he sees talent in India, and it's talent that needs to be given a chance, hence the opening of the iOS app development accelerator, planed for next year. Additionally, several hundred million dollars will be put in the Maps development facility. One challenge that the company is facing is bringing certified pre-owned devices to the country, which has so far been limited by gover...